Egg Thieves in the Coop? How to Stop Chickens From Eating Their Own Eggs

You went to grab fresh eggs and got served… scrambled drama. Instead of a full basket, you found a coop crime scene—and your prime suspect is still strutting around like nothing happened.

🥚 Someone’s been snacking on the merchandise.

If your girls have gone rogue and started eating their own eggs, don’t panic—but don’t ignore it either. Once this naughty habit sets in, it can spread faster than gossip at the feed store. The good news? It’s fixable. Let’s crack open the reasons behind egg-eating and how to stop it, fast.

Why Do Chickens Start Eating Eggs?

Contrary to the old saying, they’re not just being jerks. There’s usually a trigger:

🧠 Boredom

Hens are clever little creatures. If their day lacks excitement, they’ll create their own chaos—like pecking at that one cracked egg out of sheer curiosity. Cue: accidental discovery of delicious gooey goodness.

🧂 Nutritional Deficiencies

Low calcium or protein can send your girls looking for nutrients wherever they can find them—including inside their own freshly laid eggs. Yikes.

💪 Try this: Flock Pro Super Flock Supplement
It’s loaded with vitamins, minerals, and the protein boost your hens need to stay out of trouble.

🥚 Thin or Broken Shells

Sometimes, the problem starts with weak eggs that crack under the hen’s weight. One peck leads to another, and… boom. Habit formed.

🐚 Pro tip: Make sure your girls have free-choice oyster shell available at all times to support strong shell formation.
🪨 Need an easy setup? Our grit feederworks perfectly for offering oyster shell or grit without the mess.

🏚 Poor Nesting Setup

No nest box privacy? Not enough padding? Nowhere for eggs to roll safely out of reach? That’s a setup for disaster.

🪟 Chickens love a little privacy when laying. If they're feeling exposed or stressed, they might peck or trample eggs instead of leaving them alone.

😰 Stress & Overcrowding

Too many birds in one space = stressed out, cranky hens who act out in all kinds of problematic ways.

How to Stop Egg Eating for Good

Now that we know why, let’s fix it. Here’s your egg-thief takedown plan:

✅ 1. Upgrade to Smarter Nest Boxes

Standard boxes just don’t cut it for some flocks. Try these options to protect your eggs and give your hens the privacy they crave:

✅ 2. Boost Their Diet with the Right Supplements

Even if you’re feeding a balanced ration, laying hens often need extra support.

💊 Add in Flock Pro Super Flock for better shells, better health, and fewer egg-related “accidents.”

✅ 3. Fight Boredom with Toys & Treats

Busy birds don’t break eggs. Give them something else to peck at (besides breakfast).

🎁 Try these:
Hanging Treat Skewers
Treat Balls &Foraging Toys
Healthy Snacksto keep them occupied

✅ 4. Nest Like a Pro

Make sure you’ve got:

  • At least 1 box for every 4 hens

  • Clean, cozy nesting material

  • Curtains or dividers for privacy

  • Daily egg collection (seriously—don’t wait until afternoon!)

✅ 5. Use Decoy Eggs to Break the Habit

Sometimes, you’ve gotta outsmart the offender. Wooden or ceramic eggs can confuse peck-happy hens—they’ll try to crack 'em, fail, and give up on the whole idea.

🥚 Bonus: These also help new layers figure out where they’re supposed to deposit the goods.
Pro tip: Put one or two in each nesting box and watch the magic happen.

✅ 6. Create a Zen Den with Nesting Herbs

Adding calming herbs like lavender, chamomile, and mint to the nesting boxes can help reduce stress and keep hens relaxed—which means less frantic pecking and more peaceful laying.

🌿 Plus, they make the coop smell amazing and can naturally repel pests. Win-win.

🪴 Looking to upgrade your nest box vibe? Toss a handful of nesting herbs into each box when you clean.

But Wait—Is It True That Once They Start, They’ll Never Stop?

It’s a myth that one taste turns a hen into a permanent egg-eater. With the right changes to diet, environment, and enrichment, most birds can unlearn the habit.

So don’t start culling hens just yet. Start with prevention and smart fixes—you’ll be surprised how fast things turn around.

 Your “Egg-Eater Fix” Kit

Stop the sabotage with these Cluck It All picks:

  • Nesting box

  • Enrichment Items

  • Treats

  • Nesting Herbs

Final Cluck

Egg-eating is a hen-sized headache—but it doesn’t mean your flock is doomed. A few changes to the coop setup, diet, and daily routine can send those egg-thieving ways packing. Keep it fun, stay proactive, and remember: a bored chicken is just a little feathered tornado waiting to happen. 

Let’s Hatch a Conversation: Contact Cluck It All Farms Today!

Feeling egg-cited by what you’ve read? Or maybe you’ve hatched a brilliant idea that you can’t wait to share? Don’t fly the coop—let’s talk! Hit the button below and tell us what’s scratching at your coop door. We’re all ears and feathers!